Do Police Officers Get Fired for Misconduct? How the Process Really Works
Short answer: yes, police officers do get fired for misconduct — every year, in departments across the country. Excessive force, dishonesty, and crimes like DUI or theft regularly end officers’ jobs. But a firing is often not the end of the story. Union contracts and civil service rules give officers powerful appeal rights, outside arbitrators overturn a large share of firings, and an officer who stays fired can sometimes simply get hired by a different department. That gap between “fired” and “gone for good” is where most of the controversy lives.
Key point: Being fired and being decertified are two different things. Firing costs an officer one job. Decertification — losing the state license to work as a police officer — is what actually ends the career. Many fired officers are never decertified.
How Firing a Police Officer Actually Works, Step by Step
Firing a police officer is nothing like firing most employees. A typical case moves through these stages:
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Complaint or incident | A citizen complains, a supervisor flags something, body-camera video surfaces, or an officer is arrested. |
| 2. Internal investigation | The department’s internal affairs unit (or an outside agency) investigates and writes findings: the allegation is sustained, not sustained, or the officer is exonerated. |
| 3. Pre-discipline hearing | Because officers usually have a property right in their jobs, the chief must offer a chance to respond before major discipline is imposed (a “Loudermill” hearing, named after a 1985 Supreme Court case). |
| 4. The chief’s decision | Discipline ranges from a written reprimand or suspension to demotion or termination. The chief decides — but rarely has the last word. |
| 5. Appeal | The officer can usually appeal to a civil service board or, under most union contracts, to binding arbitration, where an outside arbitrator can reduce or completely overturn the firing. |
| 6. Certification decision | Separately, the state’s licensing body (usually called a POST commission) decides whether the officer keeps the certification required to work anywhere in that state. |
Roughly half the states also have a “Law Enforcement Officer Bill of Rights” law that adds procedural protections for officers under investigation — rules about how and when they can be questioned, for example. On top of that sit union contracts negotiated city by city. All of this exists for a real reason: to stop chiefs and politicians from firing officers arbitrarily. The trade-off is that even well-founded firings can take months or years to become final.
What Misconduct Actually Gets Officers Fired?
Departments fire officers most often for these categories:
| Type of misconduct | Typical consequences |
|---|---|
| Excessive or unjustified force | Suspension up to termination, depending on severity and the officer’s record. Serious cases also bring criminal charges. |
| Dishonesty — lying in reports, in court, or to investigators | Frequently termination. Dishonesty is treated as a career-ending offense because prosecutors must disclose it (see Brady below), which can make the officer useless as a witness. |
| Criminal conduct — DUI, assault, theft, drug offenses, domestic violence | Often termination, especially for felonies. Federal law also bars anyone convicted of a felony — or a misdemeanor crime of domestic violence — from carrying a firearm, which by itself makes police work impossible. |
| Sexual misconduct | Termination and, increasingly, decertification. |
| Neglect and rule violations — sleeping on duty, mishandling evidence, repeated policy breaches | Usually progressive discipline first: reprimand, suspension, then termination if it continues. |
One dishonesty rule deserves emphasis. Under Brady v. Maryland and Giglio v. United States, prosecutors must tell defense lawyers about evidence that undermines an officer’s credibility. An officer caught lying can be placed on a “Brady list,” after which prosecutors may refuse to use their testimony at all. A police officer who cannot testify cannot do the job — which is why departments often fire for a single proven lie faster than for almost anything else.
Why Firings So Often Get Undone
This is the part of the system that surprises most people.
Arbitration reversals are common. A 2020 study by Loyola University Chicago law professor Stephen Rushin, examining hundreds of arbitration decisions, found that arbitrators reduced or overturned police discipline in about 52% of cases — and in about 46% of cases, they ordered officers who had been fired to be rehired, usually with back pay. Arbitrators often cite uneven past discipline (“another officer got a suspension for the same thing”) or procedural errors by the department.
The numbers from big departments tell the same story. A Washington Post investigation of the nation’s largest police departments found that since 2006, those departments had fired roughly 1,900 officers for misconduct — and at least 450 of them won their jobs back through appeals and arbitration.
Common reasons firings fail on appeal:
- Inconsistent discipline. If the department tolerated similar behavior before, an arbitrator may cut the punishment to match.
- Procedural mistakes. Missed deadlines, flawed investigations, or skipped steps in the union contract can sink an otherwise justified firing.
- A different judgment call. Arbitrators are allowed to substitute their own view of the “right” penalty for the chief’s — even in serious cases.
Decertification: The Step That Actually Ends a Career
Every state licenses its police officers through a standards body, usually called a POST commission (Peace Officer Standards and Training). That body can decertify an officer for serious misconduct — convictions, dishonesty, excessive force, and similar offenses — which bars them from police work anywhere in the state, no matter which department fired them.
A few important facts about how this safety net works today:
- Decertification is separate from firing and usually run by the state, not the department. An officer can be fired and keep certification, or resign during an investigation and keep it too — a gap reformers focus on.
- The National Decertification Index (NDI), run by the International Association of Directors of Law Enforcement Standards and Training (IADLEST), collects decertification records so hiring agencies can check applicants. It now holds more than 59,000 decertification records, with all 50 states and Washington, D.C. participating — though reporting is not uniform, and the database is a pointer system: it flags that an action exists and tells the agency where to get details.
- States have strengthened these laws recently. Washington state, for example, created an independent decertification process in 2021 covering officers fired for excessive force, dishonesty, and crimes (SB 5051), and California created decertification for serious misconduct in 2021 (SB 2) after being one of the few states without it.
“Wandering Officers”: Fired in One Town, Hired in the Next
When a fired officer keeps certification, nothing stops another department — often a smaller, lower-paying one — from hiring them. Researchers call these wandering officers, and the data on them is not reassuring.
A Yale Law Journal study by Ben Grunwald and John Rappaport examined records for nearly 98,000 Florida officers over three decades. It found that in any given year, roughly 1,100 officers working in Florida had previously been fired somewhere, about 800 of them for misconduct — and that wandering officers were about twice as likely to be fired again for misconduct or face a “moral character” complaint at their next job.
A recent example of how the pieces fit together: Louisville officer Myles Cosgrove, who fired shots in the 2020 raid that killed Breonna Taylor, was fired by his department in January 2021 for violating use-of-force policy. In November 2022, the Kentucky Law Enforcement Council voted not to revoke his certification — leaving him legally able to work as an officer elsewhere — and a Kentucky appeals court upheld his firing in 2023. Fired: yes. Career automatically over: no.
Two Cases That Show How Hard Firing Can Be
- Seattle (Adley Shepherd). Officer Shepherd was fired in 2014 after punching a handcuffed woman in the face, fracturing her eye socket. An arbitrator ordered him reinstated, a decision that so alarmed the federal judge overseeing Seattle’s police reforms that he publicly questioned the department’s accountability. Only after years of litigation did an appeals court allow the firing to stand, in 2019 — five years after the incident.
- East Wenatchee, Washington (Tye Sheats). During a 2016 job-application polygraph, Sheats admitted to past theft and fraud. He was eventually fired for dishonesty, but an arbitrator reversed the firing, finding the department had not proved its case to the unusually demanding standard the arbitrator applied — higher than what labor law normally requires for workplace discipline.
Are Reforms Changing Anything?
Reform efforts since 2020 have mostly aimed at the two weak points above — arbitration and wandering officers:
- Stronger decertification laws, so a firing for serious misconduct follows the officer statewide (and, through the NDI, nationwide).
- Limits on arbitration, such as barring arbitrators from reducing discipline for the most serious offenses, or giving chiefs’ decisions more deference.
- Better hiring checks, with more states requiring departments to consult the NDI and prior employers before hiring.
- Civilian oversight and transparency, including public misconduct databases in a growing number of cities and states.
Progress is uneven, and it varies enormously by state. But the direction — more decertification, more record-sharing — is consistent.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do police officers actually get fired, or is that a myth?
They do get fired — big-city departments alone fired roughly 1,900 officers for misconduct over one studied period (Washington Post). What is unusual about policing is how often those firings are later reversed on appeal, and how often a fired officer resurfaces at another department.
What is the fastest way an officer gets fired?
A felony conviction is the surest route: it usually means termination, decertification, and — because federal law bars felons from possessing firearms — no legal way to do the job. Proven dishonesty is close behind, because it can put the officer on a Brady list and destroy their value as a witness.
Can a fired police officer just get hired somewhere else?
Often, yes — unless they were also decertified. Firing is a decision by one employer; certification is the state license. If the license survives, another department can hire the officer. That is the “wandering officer” problem, and it is why decertification laws and the National Decertification Index matter.
Why is it harder to fire a police officer than other workers?
Layers of protection stack up: civil service rules, union contracts with binding arbitration, state Law Enforcement Officer Bill of Rights statutes, and the constitutional right to a hearing before losing a public job. Each was designed to prevent unfair firings; together, they also make justified firings slow and reversible.
What is the difference between being fired and being decertified?
Fired = one department ends your employment. Decertified = the state revokes your license, so no department in that state can employ you as an officer. Decertification is decided by the state POST body, often after separate proceedings, and it is reported to the national index.
Can an officer be fired for an off-duty DUI?
Yes, and officers frequently are disciplined or fired for off-duty conduct like DUI, because departments hold officers to conduct standards around the clock and a DUI can affect their license, credibility, and ability to testify. Outcomes range from suspension to termination depending on the department and the officer’s record.
This article is general information about police discipline in the U.S., not legal advice. Discipline and certification rules are set by state law and local contracts, and individual cases turn on their specific facts.
